One of things that puzzled me when I started looking at the census reports for the Goldschlagers between 1905
and 1915 was where they were living. I had always assumed that my grandfather, like my Brotman ancestors, had settled in the Lower East Side when he arrived in New York. I thought that was where all poor Jewish immigrants had settled in the late 19th and early 20th century. Yet at the time of the 1905 census, my grandfather was living at 2213 Second Avenue, near the intersection with 115th Street, in the neighborhood we know as East Harlem or Spanish Harlem. He was living by himself (at age 17) in a building with some families with Jewish names but mostly families with Italian names. What was he doing there? Why was he living up there and not on the Lower East Side?
When Moritz arrived, they remained in East Harlem on 109th Street, and after Moritz died, Betty and Isadore moved in with Tillie on 109th Street. In 1915, all of the surviving Goldschlagers were still living on 109th Street. Eventually, Isadore moved to Brooklyn, and David, Betty and their mother moved to the Bronx, until Betty and Gisella moved to Bayshore, Long Island in the 1930s. But why had they started and stayed in East Harlem?
330 East 109th Street today
Some quick research revealed that East Harlem was a huge Jewish community in the early years of the 20th century, but that that community had disappeared and was for the most part forgotten. As David W. Dunlap wrote in The New York Times in 2002, “On the map of the Jewish diaspora, Harlem is Atlantis. That it was once the third largest Jewish settlement in the world after the Lower East Side and Warsaw — a vibrant hub of industry, artistry and wealth — is all but forgotten. It is as if Jewish Harlem sank 70 years ago beneath the waves of memory, beyond recall.” Dunlap then described the many signs that Jews once lived in East Harlem in the churches that were once synagogues.
Mount Olivet Baptist Church in East Harlem, originally Temple Israel
The neighborhood had been rural until the subway and elevated trains arrived around 1880. Soon after tenement buildings were constructed, and immigrants moved in, first German and Irish immigrants, then Jewish and Italian immigrants. According to Wikipedia, there were 90,000 Jews living in East Harlem in 1917; however, the neighborhood was predominantly Italian and came to be known as Italian Harlem or Little Italy. That is consistent with my study of the names in the 1905 census.
My mother remembers that her father spoke several languages and was quite fluent in Italian. He must have learned Italian living in East Harlem in his first ten years in New York. He was not a religious person and had left Romania at least in part to escape the anti-Semitism there. Perhaps living in a mixed neighborhood made him feel more American, although obviously there was a well-established Jewish community there as well with many synagogues and other institutions. Maybe it was cheaper than the Lower East Side, maybe the Lower East Side was already filled beyond overcrowding, or maybe East Harlem was a better neighborhood, not a cheaper neighborhood. I don’t know what drew my grandfather there or why he stayed.
It’s always good to learn something new. Now I know not only something new about my family, but also something new about the history of New York City and the Jewish immigrants who settled there.