My Cousin Anna Seghers: Activist, Author, and Survivor

The youngest child of Helene Goldschmidt and Salomon Fuld was their daughter Hedwig, born in 1880 and married to Isidor Lutz Reiling. They had one daughter, Netti, born in Mainz, Germany, in 1900. Hedwig was my third cousin, twice removed, and her daughter Netti was my fourth cousin, once removed. Their stories are those of tragedy and triumph.

Hedwig did not share the good fortune of her older siblings. She and her husband Isidor were still living in Mainz in 1940 when Isidor died on March 10 at the age of 72.

Isidor Reiling death record, Year Range: Sterberegister 1940, Band 1 Mainz, Germany, Deaths, 1876-1950. Original data: Personenstandsregister, Sterberegister, 1876-1950. Mainz Stadtarchiv.

Hedwig did not get out of Germany in time. She was deported to the ghetto in Plaski, Poland, on March 21, 1942, and was murdered sometime thereafter by the Nazis. The record on Yad Vashem has no date or place of her death.

This Page of Testimony filed by her cousin Regina Blanche Rosenberger1 indicates that she was killed in a concentration camp, but does not name which one or when. Thus, Hedwig was one of the millions of Jews whose deaths were not recorded by the Nazis, but who were murdered by them.

Hedwig Fuld Reiling, Page of Testimony, Yad Vashem at

Hedwig and Isidor’s daughter Netti did survive. If you look at the Page of Testimony above, you will see that Hedwig was identified as “mother of the author Anna Seghers.” Anna Seghers was Netti Reiling’s pseudonym, and she was a well-known author. Because of her renown, I was able to find a treasure trove of material about Netti including some old photographs.2

Isidor Reiling was an art expert and antique dealer like so many of his Goldschmidt in-laws. His daughter Netti developed an interest in art history, and in 1920 she moved to Heidelberg to attend the university there. She wrote her doctoral thesis on “Aspects of Jews and Jewishness in the Work of Rembrandt.”

It was while she was at the university in Heidelberg that she joined a group of left-wing intellectuals and met her husband, Laszlo Radvanyi. Laszlo was born in Budapest, Hungary on December 13, 1900. He studied economics and philosophy at the University of Budapest in 1918 and became interested in radical politics. He eventually ended up at the University of Heidelberg and continued his studies there.

In August 1925, Netti and Laszlo were married. Each had adopted a pseudonym for their writings. Netti became Anna Seghers, inspired by a Dutch artist Hercules Seghers whom she had studied at the university. Laszlo’s pseudonym was Johann Lorenz Schmidt after an 18th century German theologian. They had two children, Peter (later known as Pierre)(1926) and Ruth (1928) and were living in Berlin in 1928.

Seghers published her first novel The Revolt of the Fisherman in 1928, the same year she joined the Communist Party in Germany. She published a second book of short stories about poor workers in 1930 and two more books in 1932 and 1933.

Her left-wing views resulted in her books being banned when Hitler came to power in January, 1933, and she was even briefly arrested, according to some sources.  According to her son Pierre, he was sick with scarlet fever at the time, and his mother had taken him to a children’s home in the Black Forest to recover. When she heard of the Reichstag fire on February 27, 1933, she returned to Berlin. The Nazis claimed that communists had set the fire, and Netti/Anna was denounced by a neighbor. The police showed up at their home to arrest her. According to Ruth, the police did not remain long because they were afraid of catching scarlet fever. Whether or not Netti/Anna was ever taken into custody seems unclear.

The family left Germany soon thereafter and escaped to France. They lived in Paris for seven years where Laszlo started a free university for German refugees; he continued to work on anti-fascist, left-wing causes; Netti/Anna published several books during this time and also spent some time in Vienna and in Spain during the Spanish Civil War.

As a Hungarian and known communist, Laszlo/Johann was interned as a “suspected national” by the French in a camp in southern France. When the Nazis invaded France and occupied Paris in the spring of 1940, Netti/Anna and the children hid in Paris until they were able to escape to Marseilles. They were eventually able to free Laszlo and leave France on March 24, 1941, when the family sailed to the US and ultimately Mexico, where they settled.

During their time in Mexico, Anna Seghers wrote her best known book, The Seventh Cross, about seven political prisoners who escape from a Nazi concentration camp. It was first published in the United States and Mexico in 1942 and became the basis of a 1944 film of the same title starring Spencer Tracy, Hume Cronyn, Jessica Tandy, and Agnes Moorehead.

The New York Times review of the film in 1944 is quite interesting. The reviewer, Bosley Crowther, found Spencer Tracy’s performance “splendid” and Jessica Tandy’s “emotionally devastating.” He described the plot as “hair-raising” and the production as filled with “crackling tension and hard-packed realism” and as preserving the “monstrousness” of Segher’s book.3

But Crowther found reason to criticize the film as being too soft on the Germans:

Without in the least overlooking the bestiality of the Nazi brutes nor the miserable self-surrender of German citizens to their black regime, this film … visions a burning zeal for freedom in some German rebels and a core of decency in common folk. …[T]he basic theme…is that in men—even in Germans—there is an instinct for good that cannot be destroyed.….

The big reservation which this writer holds with regard to this film is that regarding the discretion of its theme at this particular time. Without any question, it creates a human sympathy for the people of a nation with whom we are at war and it tends, as have others, to load Germany’s crimes on Nazi backs. Obviously this film can make sentiment for a “soft” peace. It looks as though we are getting a dandy “thriller” at a pretty high price.

I have not yet read the book nor seen the film, but hope to do one or the other while being confined during this pandemic. There are more current reviews of the book, including this one from The New York Review of Books written upon the publication of a new translation of the book in 2018:

The Seventh Cross is one of the most powerful, popular, and influential novels of the twentieth century, a hair raising thriller that helped to alert the world to the grim realities of Nazi Germany and that is no less exciting today than when it was first published in 1942. … Anna Seghers’s novel is not only a supremely suspenseful story of flight and pursuit but also a detailed portrait of a nation in the grip and thrall of totalitarianism.

Anna Seghers wrote a number of other books while living in Mexico. It was also during this time that she learned that her mother had been killed by the Nazis. Nevertheless, after the war she and her family returned to Germany, first West Berlin, later East Berlin. She continued to be a left wing and communist political activist and to write books based on her political views for the rest of her life. She was a loyal supporter of the Soviet Union and East Germany.

Laszlo Radanvanyi died on July 3, 1978, in Berlin. Like his wife, he had remained a political activist as well as a professor. Netti/Anna died five years later on June 1, 1983, in Berlin.

Rüdiger Wölk,  Münster,  CC BY-SA (

On November 19, 2000, the German publication Der Welt published an interview with Netti and Laszlo’s two adult children, Pierre and Ruth, which revealed a more personal perspective on their mother. Ruth described her as “very warm, a normal mother,” and Pierre said she was “a very intuitive, extremely sensitive, even compassionate woman.”

Ruth Radanyi died on July 18, 2010 at the age of 82. Her brother Pierre, an author and physicist, is still living as far as I can tell. At this link, you can hear him read one of his mother’s poems.

The story of Netti Reiling/Anna Seghers and her family is yet another example of the literary talents of the Goldschmidt family as well as another example of the courage and resilience of the human spirit in the face of devastating hatred and danger. Although it may be hard to understand how Netti could support the totalitarianism of the Soviet Union, I cannot judge her for her views, given what she endured and what she lost as a young woman.

Bundesarchiv, Bild 183-P1202-317 / Sturm, Horst / CC-BY-SA 3.0 / CC BY-SA 3.0 DE (

  1. Regina Blanche Rosenberg was born Regina Blanche Goldschmidt, and she was the daughter of Julius Goldschmidt, younger brother Helene Goldschmidt Fuld, Hedwig Fuld Reiling’s mother. That is, she was Hedwig’s first cousin. Regina immigrated to Canada and died in 1992. More on Regina when I get to her father’s story. 
  2. Since I don’t know when these works were first published, I can’t determine whether they are in the public domain—even though many of them were taken before 1923. See  Thus, I won’t be posting them, tempting as it might be to do so. But if you follow some of the links in the post, you will be able to see the photos. 
  3. Bosley Crowther, “The Seventh Cross, Anti-Nazi Drama, with Spencer Tracy, at Capitol,” The New York Times, September 29, 1944, p. 18. 

22 thoughts on “My Cousin Anna Seghers: Activist, Author, and Survivor

  1. What a great discovery you made in your family research, Amy! I found the English translation on Amazon as a Kindle edition and I am going to order it for my reading during this time of self-isolation. The criticism of Anna Seghers’ book and the movie of 1944 is understandable considering that the United States was at war with Nazi Germany. I have learned that we need to make a distinction between the government of a totalitarian state and its people. Yes, many people in Germany saw in Hitler a person who had rescued them from the humiliating dictates of the Versailles Treaty, but there were also many people who opposed his radical views and the cruel dictatorial measures against the Jews, communists, many others. I believe Anna’s book is just as relevant today as it was when it was written. Thank you, Amy, for also providing the interesting links to her biography!

    Liked by 1 person

    • It was so interesting to read that review and get a taste for what people were thinking. To condemn a whole nation is not right. However, we also have to remember that most Germans went along with what Hitler was doing and did not resist. Maybe it was out of fear of being persecuted themselves, maybe it was because Nazi propaganda was so persuasive, but far too many people in Germany (and in many other countries, including Austria, Poland, and France) were at best acquiescent and at worst complicit with the persecution policies of Hitler and his henchman.

      Now I need to order my own copy of her book! Thanks, Peter.

      Liked by 1 person

      • Most people in Germany had no clue what was happening in the concentration camps. Most of them were located in remote areas in the eastern occupied territories far away from the public eye. In that sense we cannot burden the entire German people with guilt. The Nuremberg Trials dealt with the perpetrators and provided the evidence for the hideous crimes of the Nazi leaders.
        Have a great and relaxing weekend , AmY!

        Liked by 1 person

      • I have to believe that virtually everyone in Germany knew about the Nuremberg Laws. They knew that Jews were being arrested, that stores were being boycotted and vandalized, that Jews were being thrown out of their jobs and the schools. Whether or not they knew the details of what was happening in the concentration camps before 1942 or so is less clear. But as I said, most Germans knew that Jews were being persecuted (even if they didn’t know they were being murdered) and did little or nothing to stop it. They may not have been Nazis or supported what was happening, but that’s not the same as stopping it or arguing against it. People in areas where there were no Jews may have been less aware, but anyone who had a radio or read a newspaper knew what Hitler was saying and what his followers were doing. This book argues that they knew even more:

        Don’t get me wrong. I am not condemning the German people as a whole. Many were brave and resisted what was happening. Many protected their Jewish friends. And for those who didn’t, these were often decisions based on fear, not hatred. I am not sure how any of us would have responded. I believe that most people are good, but also flawed, and that very few of us are as courageous as we should be.

        Liked by 1 person

      • Thank you, Amy, for the information! Fear was definitely a factor. I think even today there is a lesson to be learned. It takes courage to speak out, even in a democracy, against all forms of injustices. For those who live in relative comfort and safety it is often too easy to look the other way or ignore in apathy persons who make racially motivated remarks or even resort to violence. I also appeal to you not to misunderstand me. I am not trying to defend the atrocities perpetrated by Nazis, nor the Mitläufer controlled by the Nazi newspapers and radio propaganda. I hope my various blog posts on my family made this abundantly clear.

        Liked by 1 person

      • Of course, I understood that. I think that many Germans of the post-war generation were shocked to learn what had happened as the older generation never talked about what they knew. Many of the people I met in Germany who were born during or after the war only learned as teens or adults what had happened and are doing all they can to preserve the history and memory of the Jews of Germany. And I think many others are still in denial and can’t believe that their parents and grandparents knew what was happening until after the war.

        As I said, people knew, but were too afraid (or sadly in many cases too complicit) to do anything to stop it. And yes, unfortunately it’s still true today. It’s easier to go along than to stand up and speak out. I am as likely to be cowardly as anyone, and I am ashamed to admit that.

        Liked by 1 person

  2. An amazing posting about an amazing woman and her family. I did go over to hear her son read the poem, it was beautiful to listen to in French and see his photo and what a wonderful photo of Netti/Anna. I would love to watch the movie and while I don’t have kindle it would love to track down and English version of the book, books 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

    • I can’t find the movie online except as a DVD, and we no longer have a DVD player. So I will have to keep searching for it online. I did download the book to my Kindle and will read it once I finish the book I am currently reading.

      Thanks, Sharon.


  3. What an amazing story. I do have a DVD player so I will look for the DVD – probably a better chance that I’d watch that than, gasp, read a book. 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

  4. Amy, what a fascinating story. I think a biography or nonfiction novel could be written about Netti’s life that is as much a thriller as the books she wrote.


  5. Pingback: Friday's Family History Finds | Empty Branches on the Family Tree

  6. Pingback: Leni and Julius Falk Goldschmidt and Their Sons: Escaping from Germany | Brotmanblog: A Family Journey

  7. Pingback: Anna Segher’s The Seventh Cross: A Story of Moral Choices | Brotmanblog: A Family Journey

  8. Pingback: My Goldschmidt Family Project: Looking Back and Looking Forward | Brotmanblog: A Family Journey

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.